Oura Ring Vs Whoop After 100 Nights - Tough Choice

‍
I've been tracking my own sleep everyday for years and have helped thousands of people improve their sleep through my content and my course, Sleep Advantage. One of the most frequent questions I get is, "Kyle, which do you prefer, the Whoop or the Oura Ring, and what would you recommend?" In this article, I'm going to break down what I like and what I don't like about both of them so that hopefully by the end, you'll be able to make an informed decision about which one is right for you.
‍

The Whoop Wristband

The Whoop is a fitness and health tracking wristband that can provide detailed insights into your body’s performance, recovery, and sleep. It uses various sensors to collect data around the clock, offering a continuous stream of information to help you optimize your health and fitness routines.

Key Features:

1. Sleep Tracking: Monitors sleep stages, duration, and quality.
2. Recovery Analysis: Measures heart rate variability (HRV), resting heart rate, and sleep performance to provide a daily recovery percentage.
3. Strain Tracking: Automatically tracks physical activity and provides a strain score to help users balance training and recovery.
4. Heart Rate Monitoring: Provides real-time heart rate data during workouts and daily activities.
5. Journal Feature: Allows logging of habits, activities, and lifestyle factors to see their impact on sleep and recovery.

‍

The Oura Ring

The Oura Ring is a sleek, smart ring that too tracks your sleep, activity, and overall health. It’s known for its advanced sleep tracking capabilities and its ability to provide detailed insights into your readiness for the day.

Key Features:

1. Sleep Tracking: Provides detailed analysis of sleep stages, duration, and efficiency.
2. Readiness Score: Combines data from sleep, HRV, body temperature, and activity levels to give a daily readiness score.
3. Activity Tracking: Monitors daily activity levels and encourages balanced activity.
4. Heart Rate Monitoring: Tracks resting heart rate and HRV.
5. Temperature Monitoring: Measures body temperature deviations, which can indicate illness or stress.

‍

Price

The Oura Ring costs $299 with a $6 monthly subscription, while the Whoop comes with a $20 to $30 monthly subscription, and you get the band for free. Over three years, the Oura Ring will cost $515, whereas the Whoop will cost $1,080 at $30 per month or $720 at $20 per month.

Winner: Oura Ring for its lower overall cost.

‍

Comfort

Both devices are comfortable with some caveats. The Oura Ring is generally comfortable but can be inconvenient during weightlifting as it gets in the way of gripping the bar/dumbell. The Whoop is comparison has no problems when working out but I find myself having to readjust it at times, if its pressing too hard on my wrist.

Winner: Tie, as both have unique issues.

‍

Data Accuracy

Both devices are quite accurate, but there are slight differences. From my experience, the Oura Ring tends to report higher deep sleep, while the Whoop shows higher REM sleep. I've noticed that people who typically complain about 'how these trackers aren't accurate or are misrepresenting what their sleep actually is' are often those with poor sleep quality. Based on what I've seen in my own data when I sleep well it's reflected in the data when I don't sleep well it's reflected, indicating that both devices reflect sleep patterns reliably.

Both devices also do a great job at tracking real time stress but I do have an issue with Whoops strain score process. Whoops strain algorithm is based upon heart rate, and hence aerobic exercise provides a significantly higher strain than weight lifting. Therefore the whoop may tell you you're ready to exert yourself despite feeling very sore and fatigued the day or two after lifting.

Winner: Whoop, slightly more accurate based on evidence (Check out The Quantified Scientist for more data analysis)

‍

Data Display

The Oura Ring excels in data display. It provides sleep and readiness scores almost immediately upon waking, whereas the Whoop can take up to 30-40 minutes to load data. I also find the Oura Ring's interface is more user-friendly and easier to navigate, especially for those new to sleep tracking.

Winner: Oura Ring for its quick and user-friendly data display.

‍
‍

Logging Data

Every time you wake up Whoop gives you a prompt to fill in your 'journal' and in this journal you can pick different habits or different supplements or lifestyle interventions that you can tick off say hey I did this yesterday or write personalized notes. Over time this builds a database of habits, supplements or what type of workout you did and how it can impact your sleep, recovery or your strain. I love this because at the end of week or month is provides a report with all the data laid out do that you can see what behaviors are most impacting you and what are the things that actually move the needle the most. Oura Ring's logging feature on the other hand is less developed and less useful.

Winner: Whoop for its comprehensive logging and analysis features.

‍

Cloud Data and Coaching

Oura Ring offers a cloud data feature where users can share data with coaches, making it a lot easier for coaches to analyze and provide feedback without logging into the app or having to take and share screenshots. Whoop has integrated AI coaching with ChatGPT, which is promising but not as established.

Winner: Oura Ring for its accessible cloud data feature.

‍

Charging and Battery Life

Both devices are easy to charge. The Oura Ring charges on a stand within a couple hours, while the Whoop uses a portable puck that is charged individually and then used to charge the band wirelessly.  An issue I have with this set up is that although wireless charging is great and you never have ti take off the Whoop, it's puck is incredibly easy to lose and costs at least $50 to replace. The Oura ring is said to last up to 7 days when fully charged while the Whoop lasts from 4-5 days.

Winner: Tie, as both have their pros and cons in this area.

‍

‍

Workout Tracking

Whoop provides real-time heart rate zone tracking, which is really beneficial for those who want to do zone training and build aerobic fitness. The Whoop also automatically detects and logs activities better than the Oura Ring, which often misses workouts. For example, whether you're playing volleyball or going for a bike ride or working out it generally I would say picks up and logs some activity and you can then go into the app and update the activity type and times if needed. Considering, I have to take my Oura ring off for most of my workouts, the Whoop easily wins in this category.

Winner: Whoop for superior workout tracking capabilities.

‍

EMF Exposure

Whoop emits very high EMF levels and does not have an airplane mode, which can be a concern for some users especially those who sleep with their wrists near their faces. The Oura Ring, while also emitting EMF, has an airplane mode that still collects data, reducing your EMF exposure when sleep. High EMF exposure has been linked to potential headaches, sleep disturbances, memory and concentration issues and and if exposed in the long term some studies suggest a potential link to certain types of cancer.

Winner: Oura Ring for its lower EMF exposure and airplane mode.

‍

Conclusion

Having a wearable device is an absolute game changer for your health and they keep ypu accountable and allow you to be more conscious of the impact of your decisions. I wholeheartedly think both the Whoop and Oura Ring are excellent devices but come with with unique strengths and weaknesses, that suit one person over another. The Oura ring wins in terms of cost, data display, cloud data sharing, and EMF exposure while the Whoop excels in data accuracy, logging data, and workout tracking.

For me, the Oura Ring stands out due to its cost-effectiveness and airplane mode, however, I still use the Whoop for its fitness tracking capabilities. We will have to see which one I stick with in the longterm.
‍

For the complete video review, click here.